Terraform Error: Cycle: resource dependency

A cyclic dependency is detected between resources.

Resolving Cyclic Dependency Errors in Terraform

Understanding Terraform

Terraform is an open-source Infrastructure as Code (IaC) tool created by HashiCorp. It allows developers to define and provision data center infrastructure using a high-level configuration language. Terraform is widely used for managing cloud services and on-premises infrastructure, enabling consistent and repeatable infrastructure deployment.

Identifying the Symptom

When working with Terraform, you might encounter the error message: Error: Cycle: resource dependency. This error indicates that Terraform has detected a cyclic dependency between resources in your configuration. Such cycles prevent Terraform from determining the correct order of operations, leading to a failure in applying the configuration.

Example of the Error

Consider a scenario where you have two resources, resource_a and resource_b, each depending on the other:

resource "aws_instance" "resource_a" {
depends_on = [aws_instance.resource_b]
}

resource "aws_instance" "resource_b" {
depends_on = [aws_instance.resource_a]
}

This configuration creates a cycle, as each resource waits for the other to be created first.

Understanding the Issue

A cyclic dependency occurs when two or more resources depend on each other, creating a loop. Terraform requires a directed acyclic graph (DAG) to determine the order of resource creation. Cycles disrupt this process, as Terraform cannot resolve which resource should be created first.

Why Cycles Occur

Cycles often occur due to misconfigured dependencies or assumptions about resource creation order. They can also arise from complex configurations where implicit dependencies are not clearly defined.

Steps to Fix the Issue

To resolve cyclic dependencies, you need to refactor your Terraform configuration to break the cycle. Here are the steps to do so:

1. Analyze the Dependency Graph

Use the terraform graph command to visualize the dependency graph. This command generates a DOT format graph that you can view using graph visualization tools like Graphviz. This visualization helps identify cycles and understand the dependency relationships.

terraform graph | dot -Tsvg > graph.svg

2. Refactor Dependencies

Identify and refactor the dependencies causing the cycle. Use the depends_on argument to explicitly define dependencies where necessary. Ensure that no resource directly or indirectly depends on itself.

3. Introduce Intermediate Resources

In some cases, introducing intermediate resources can help break the cycle. For example, if two resources depend on each other, consider creating a third resource that both depend on, thereby breaking the direct cycle.

4. Validate the Configuration

After refactoring, validate your configuration using the terraform validate command to ensure there are no syntax errors or unresolved dependencies.

terraform validate

Conclusion

By understanding and addressing cyclic dependencies in Terraform, you can ensure smooth and error-free infrastructure deployment. For more detailed guidance, refer to the official Terraform documentation.

Never debug

Terraform

manually again

Let Dr. Droid create custom investigation plans for your infrastructure.

Book Demo
Automate Debugging for
Terraform
See how Dr. Droid creates investigation plans for your infrastructure.

MORE ISSUES

Made with ❤️ in Bangalore & San Francisco 🏢

Doctor Droid